Spoliation in Canada: More Than Just Missing Evidence
The destruction of relevant evidence can significantly impact the fairness of litigation. When a party intentionally destroys evidence that may be relevant to a dispute, courts have long recognized the doctrine of spoliation as a mechanism to address the resulting prejudice.
The Supreme Court of Canada last addressed the doctrine of spoliation in its seminal 1986 decision of St. Louis v. The Queen, 25 S.C.R. 649. Back then spoilation meant the physical destruction of documents or evidence. In the digital age, spoilation can occur in an instant and at the click of a button. In its recent decision, SS&C Technologies Canada Corp. v. Bank of New York Mellon Corp., 2026 SCC 29, the Supreme Court provides guidance on the modern approach to spoliation in Canada.
Background Facts
The case arose from a dispute between SS&C Technologies Canada Corporation, a provider of securities pricing data, and Bank of New York Mellon Corporation (BNY). Under a licensing agreement, BNY was prohibited from sharing SS&C’s proprietary data with affiliates or third parties. In 2016, SS&C discovered that BNY had been providing the data to affiliated entities. SS&C demanded that BNY preserve records showing how the data had been distributed and used, but BNY failed to do so. SS&C subsequently terminated the agreement and sued BNY for breach of contract. The resulting dispute over the destruction and non-production of those records ultimately led the Supreme Court to clarify the test for spoliation.
The Four Part Test for Spoliation
The Court confirmed that a party alleging spoliation bears the burden of proving all four elements on a balance of probabilities:
The fourth requirement is particularly significant. The Court emphasized that spoliation is not merely about the disappearance of evidence. Rather, the doctrine is engaged where there is an intention to interfere with the litigation process by destroying relevant evidence.
The Presumption Against the Spoliator
Where the party alleging spoliation successfully establishes all four elements, the Court held that a presumption arises that the destroyed evidence would have been unfavourable to the spoliator’s case.
At that point, the burden shifts to the party responsible for the destruction of the evidence. The spoliator may rebut the presumption by demonstrating that the missing evidence was not harmful to its position. However, if the presumption is not
rebutted, adverse inferences must be drawn against the spoliator.
The Court also recognized that even where the presumption applies, the spoliator may still lead evidence to narrow the scope of the adverse inferences that should be
drawn.
The Court also confirmed that establishing spoliation does not automatically result in the most severe possible consequence. The appropriate remedy remains discretionary and must be tailored to the circumstances of the case. The Court rejected the argument that a finding of spoliation should automatically entitle the innocent party to the most favourable inference or “maximum penalty.” Instead, courts retain flexibility to fashion other remedies where appropriate.
Unanswered Questions
While the decision provides clarity on the test for establishing spoliation, the Court left two important issues unresolved.
First, the Court expressly declined to decide whether negligent destruction of evidence can amount to spoliation. Second, it did not determine whether Canada should recognize an independent tort of spoliation, which could potentially provide a separate cause of action for parties prejudiced by the destruction of evidence.
The Court stated:
“Whether negligent destruction of evidence may qualify as spoliation, and whether spoliation should be recognized as an independent tort in Canada, are open questions in Canadian law. Without the benefit of full submissions, we leave these issues for another day.”
As a result, both issues remain open for future consideration by Canadian courts.
Key Takeaways
The key takeaway from the decision is that intention matters. Parties seeking a spoliation finding must do more than establish that relevant evidence no longer exists. They must prove intentional destruction and a litigation-related purpose behind that destruction. The mere loss or destruction of evidence will not automatically amount to spoliation. At the same time, the decision underscores the importance of preserving potentially relevant evidence, including digital evidence, once litigation is reasonably contemplated, as the intentional destruction of such evidence can attract serious consequences.
While the Court has clarified the circumstances in which spoliation will be established, it also signaled that the law in this area is still evolving. The questions of negligent spoliation and whether a standalone tort of spoilation should exist, remain very much alive and will undoubtedly be the subject of future consideration.